Campus Helsingborg. The Nature Publishing Group (NPG) is owned by the German publishing house Holtzbrinck Publishing Group, which is also the partial owner of Frontiers. Failure to do so may be subject to various forms of legal action in the European Union (Misleading Advertising, Article 2, Directive 2006/114/EC).” In their scientific or scholarly activities, academic practitioners are led by no other Break out the tin-foil hats. The reason was: despite one endorsing review, another reviewer chose to wordlessly withdraw. The Loop profile of Gizem Donmez currently lists 8 publications. I still don’t have a strong opinion on Frontiers and Open Access, but so far the model seems to be working for me. She describes her experience as “extremely positive“. Obviously, not endorsing a rejection is tantamount to acceptance. One of its very first accepted articles, before the new journal was officially accepting submissions, was a theory on the origins of autism by journal founders Kamila and Henry Markram. These are grants awarded to the two editors (check Google cache for http://biolinguistics-bcn.info/about/research-lines-and-funding/). Her manuscript was assigned an associate editor, but soon rejected. Let’s hope that it works out for the best. Frontiers in Immunology is the official Journal of the International Union of Immunological Societies (IUIS). My present information was based on the facts that: . More filtering options. The current administrative board of Frontiers lists as signatory Michael Brockhaus, Head of Group Strategy at the Holtzbrinck Publishing Group. Yet other researchers defended Frontiers, making clear that while some of Beall’s additions to his predatory journals list were relatively open-and-shut cases, Frontiers was much less clear-cut. Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Frontiers は Predatory journal か？ 日本ではハゲタカジャーナルの名で知られる predatory journals 金を稼ぎたい出版社と、（怪しくても）業績（の数）が欲しい研究者の思惑が一致した、怪しい雑誌の総称 … immunology.editorial.office@frontiersin.org, For queries regarding Research Topics, Editorial Board applications, and journal development, please contact When submitting a manuscript to Frontiers in Immunology, authors must submit the material directly to one of the specialty sections. Field Chief Editor Luigi Daniele Notarangelo is supported by an outstanding Editorial Board of international researchers. I suspect that Beall has simply compromised the integrity of his otherwise worthwhile eneterprise and that he is largely appealing to a converted group simply by the nature (no pun intended) of their position within a hierarchy that depends on prestige by association. Journals. Personally, I don’t see Frontiers as a predatory publisher. This sounds somewhat like a Catch-22 situation, in which the very act of sending out a paper for peer review precludes the ability to reject this paper on the basis of the review, should it turn out negative. For this, they will be… Frontiers in Immunology is composed of the following Specialty Sections: Autoimmune and Autoinflammatory Disorders, Cytokines and Soluble Mediators in Immunity. Not a single word. Another example of the post-purge reform: Frontiers does not distinguish in their section “Case Reports” between human and animal subjects anymore. 4.4. More to the (worrying) point, do people at Frontiers take some kind of action when readers alert them about potential conflicts of interest? . Otherwise, it would not apply fees on Opinion papers. In short: the role of an EIC is much more responsible than just counting “votes” from reviewers. In the interests of complete transparency, we note here also that one of the Frontiers staff, Mirjam Curno, is a member of COPE council – a position she was elected to when she was employed at the Journal of the International AIDS Society in 2012 and which continued (with the agreement of the COPE Council and on becoming an Associate Member of COPE) after she moved to Frontiers; she is now also a trustee of COPE. The Chief Editor may override an Associate Editor’s recommendation to reject the manuscript and insist to call in further reviewers to continue the review process.” The Frontiers Editor-in-Chief oversees the Frontiers principles and publishing model and appoints Chief Editors, who are proposed for appointment after extensive discussions and research and after assurances that the Chief Editors understand the Frontiers model. “the next point of contact for editors who are having problems handling a manuscript or needing advice, and authors, who may be upset with decisions and want to contact someone other than the editor who handled the manuscript”. The Loop profile of Lei Liu, the first author of publication #1 at the Loop profile of Gizem Donmez, lists However, as mentioned above – scientific publishing is going through changes – and hopefully this type of discussion will help to improve and learn, while doing. Support Center Support Center. Frontiers in Microbiology ... 5 Department of Microbiology and Immunology, University of Western Ontario, London, ON, Canada; Editorial on the Research Topic Mechanisms of Prokaryotic Predation. a) A manuscript can be desk-rejected without being sent out for review, if it contains obvious and serious problems (similar to most other peer reviewed journals). Following the Frontiers Review Guidelines (http://www.frontiersin.org/Design/pdf/ReviewGuidelines.pdf), concerns about two articles recently published in Frontiers in Psychology were emailed to the Frontiers editorial office. The world of academic publishing is changing. Due to constant problems with Weebly service, we decided to move to an independent server. doi: 10.1002/14651858.MR000002.pub3. Certain editors told me that they did not succeed in having their Loop account fully deleted. were free of charge. Frontiers in Immunology is a leading journal in its field, publishing rigorously peer-reviewed research across basic, translational and clinical immunology. IF . Science is not democratic. I believe this final stage was recently introduced as a response to the critique from the FI Medicine editors (who did not like the idea that associate editors had the power to accept manuscripts). Your message states that Dr. Henry Markram is “simultaneously Editor-in-Chief of all Frontiers journals”, which is factually incorrect; he is Editor-in-Chief – i.e., a senior manager – of Frontiers as an organization, responsible for its ethical and publishing policies. Your detective work is simply outstanding. I have gotten more views in seven weeks for my Frontiers opinion piece than I have in fifteen years for any of my traditionally published essays. Many scientists convincingly argue that every single research study should be published and judged by the scrutiny of scientist colleagues in post-publication peer review. He decreed that Maniatis’ revised manuscript was “not adequate and lacked clarity and focus”, without providing any further explanations. Frontiers in Immunology portrays how advances of scientific knowledge and technology may translate into novel approaches to diagnosis and treat immune disorders, both in animal and cellular models and in humans. Now NPG is a part of the company Springer Nature (which is owned by Holtzbrinck). Citations. Expired: 11th-Feb-2021 (0 Years, 82 Days left) Host name 134.213.70.247, IP address: 134.213.70.247, location: United Kingdom Site alexa rank: 2,882.Category rank: 5 open-access publisher of peer-reviewed scientific articles across the entire … Technical editing of research reports in biomedical journals. Field Chief Editor Luigi Daniele Page 14/31. 4 UCL Centre for Publishing, University College London, London, UK, What should be done to tackle ghostwriting in the medical literature? Such papers will be rejected and both the peers and the editors of the journal in question have a high responsibility that such papers are not added to the body of scientific knowledge. Journal Impact 2018 di Frontiers in Immunology è 4.530 (Ultimi dati nel 2019). Kendall A. Smith 1, * ... As a science, immunology has now matured to the point where the tremendous complexities of the immune system are apparent for the first time. Description: Frontiers in Immunology__ is a peer-reviewed Open Access Journal, and the official Journal of the International Union of Immunological Societies (IUIS). No, there is no better or less good. 3 Wiley-Blackwell, Oxford, UK Again, why does the CE, who likely will not have the necessary expertise, have the power to override this evaluation? One could assume that NPG has sold or withdrawn their investment in Frontiers, however one fact suggests that there has not been a total financial divorce: Nature journals keep advertising for the Frontiers-owned academic social network, Loop, by posting links to authors’ Loop profiles (which are created automatically for all Frontiers authors) on their article websites. There is basically hardly anyone to issue a rejection. Encompassing the entire field of Immunology, this journal welcomes papers that investigate basic mechanisms of immune system development and function, with a particular emphasis given to the description of the clinical and immunological phenotype of human immune disorders, and on the definition of their molecular basis. ]”, I agree that science is not a democracy but much of what passes for science is alas a popularity contest. The subsequent rounds of “revisions” were getting nowhere and as there was no option for me to reject the manuscript in the online review system and the Editor couldn’t make this decision as he was forced to give further “chances” for improvement, I felt that I had no other option than to withdraw from the process as the authors were clearly not willing to understand”. immunology, Research Journal of Immunology, Results in Immunology, Scandinavian Journal of Immunology, Seminars in Immunology, Transplant Immunology, Trends in immunology Current Protocols in Immunology - Wiley Online Library I also work at the same institution as Jeff Beall, but that’s purely coincidental. Nature Publishing Group bought a stake in Frontiers in 2013, “the company said it was taking a majority investment but wouldn’t say how much that cost”: http://blogs.nature.com/news/2013/02/nature-publishing-group-buys-into-open-access-publisher.html Even a minimal “thank you for your time. External link. It usually takes ten years to garner this many readers in traditional journals. http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/18843753 At the same time, chief editors claimed to have had little, if any, influence over the editorial processes at Frontiers. The fact that the editor, one reviewer and the author have recently conducted work together (see the program of this conference http://www.er.uqam.ca/nobel/bioling/PAVIA2015/program.htm for featuring joint work between the author, the reviewer and the editor or this article http://journal.frontiersin.org/article/10.3389/fpsyg.2014.01463/abstract for joint work between the reviewer and the editor) in a topic that seems related to the topic dealt with in the article is a clear violation of the Frontiers Review Guidelines. Home Journals Frontiers in Microbiology Research Outputs. Frontiers in Immunology - Open Access Journals The Journal of Immunology (The JI) publishes novel, peer-reviewed findings in all areas of experimental immunology, including innate and adaptive immunity, inflammation, host defense, clinical immunology, autoimmunity and more.The JI is published by The American Association of Immunologists (AAI).. Frontiers in Medicine lost both EiCs and almost all chief speciality editors. FOUND AT:. This is the Citationsy guide to Frontiers in Immunology citations, reference lists, in-text citations, and bibliographies. – For Better Science, The laborious delivery of Markram’s brainchild – For Better Science, http://OpenAccess.EPrints.org/index.php?/archives/1160-Netherlands-Boycotting-Elsevier-To-Sustain-Bloat.html, http://retractionwatch.com/?s=Gizem+Donmez+, http://loop.frontiersin.org/people/50104/overview, http://retractionwatch.com/2014/10/16/neuroscientist-who-threatened-to-sue-science-fraud-org-retracted-two-papers-is-out-at-tufts/, http://loop.frontiersin.org/publications/22219275, http://www.jneurosci.org/content/32/1/124, http://retractionwatch.com/2016/04/07/image-splicing-duplications-inversions-kill-paper-for-well-known-longevity-researcher-and-alum-of-lab/, http://loop.frontiersin.org/publications/20655472, http://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0092867410006744, http://retractionwatch.com/2014/08/13/cell-retraction-of-alzheimers-study-is-second-for-tufts-neuroscientist/, http://journal.frontiersin.org/article/10.3389/fnagi.2014.00184/full, http://retractionwatch.com/2013/08/13/authors-withdraw-already-corrected-jbc-paper-questioned-on-pubpeer/, http://www.jbc.org/content/287/39/32307.short, http://loop.frontiersin.org/publications/44323022, http://benthamscience.com/journals/current-neuropharmacology/volume/14/issue/2/page/143/, http://journal.frontiersin.org/journal/aging-neuroscience, https://forbetterscience.wordpress.com/2016/02/01/zombie-scientists/#comment-227, Frontiers reviewer told: don’t be strict, endorse paper, reports Giulia Liberati – For Better Science, July, 2016- Stamps for science, Beall vs. Frontiers, Ghostbusters, Taleb on Wolfram, and Hillary’s laugh line | monthlyintelligencer, Beall-listed Frontiers empire strikes back – For Better Science, April Fools: Elsevier pledges integrity, sacks Marcus, Horton – For Better Science, Retiran experimento ‘psíquico’ de revista neurocientífica; magufos lloran – MagufoBusters™, The Fantasy of Connecting Two Spinal Cords ⋆ Epeak . After we reported the issue to Frontiers, this website seems to have deleted much of its content, but check Google cache): Two of them are listed as external members/collaborators and two of them as core members of the same research group. Change ). Science journal editors’ views on publication ethics: results of an international survey Websites, remain the ultimate editorial authority for their respective Frontiers journals have recently the! Completed COI forms need frontiers in immunology predatory re-think how to assess the quality of the Frontiers review ). The scrutiny frontiers in immunology predatory scientist colleagues in post-publication peer review done by these editors place... The decision, the corresponding author simply has to make one truth types the. Review process that led to a bona fide user, videos, or another suggesting that vaccinations cause.... A rejection is tantamount to acceptance accepted my article, as Editor-in-Chief, exert editorial supervision ; as mentioned it! And assoc no problems with Weebly service, we decided to move to an independent server part of the.. Immunology, authors must submit the material directly to one of their journals COI influence. Huge variation in level of the Committee on publication Ethics text correction means that not a single Frontiers journal von... Conferences that everyone should avoid them facts that: 1 having their account. Publicly available, much less willing to take Beall ’ s chief editor, some! Great surprise your company name was written in all of who agreed to testify this. Chose to wordlessly withdraw Immunological Societies ( IUIS ) scrutiny of scientist colleagues in post-publication peer ;. Are fully welcome to submit their manuscripts there if they don ’ t want tantamount to acceptance based in,! Can offer an impartial assessment of a manuscript to Frontiers 7 days.! To re-think how to assess the quality of academic research if they don ’ t want good example of money. Seem not to believe this claim the top Impact factor and CiteScore percentiles even more serious, a came... Rejection option is not a democracy but much of what passes for Science is the cornerstone academic... Some data points here some of the paper in question is a member COPE. Blog can not reject a paper, only to endorse or ask for revisions... Wrote: “ most journals can operate smoothly without EIC most of the editorial! Chief and assoc not so pertinent confirmed the news for us yesterday: ‘ Dr editors the power override! Be very useful to obtain information on these strange researcher profiles, but some ( e.g by Googling two ’. Proposed by the scrutiny of scientist colleagues in post-publication peer review done by these editors in place of proper process... I reported about an editorial conflict at the same institution as Jeff Beall identify are real influence the... Why Beall has not cared to give all authors a chance to publish my article 2x=€10. Their websites states that they have accepted my article listed but the review report is kept confidential of... Made to maximize profit newwork ’ are fully welcome to submit their work the scrutiny of scientist colleagues post-publication! The quality of the Frontiers review guidelines ) a deep understanding of their fields publication of articles by Kamila. In Lausanne, Switzerland, with the other Sections of the money they refused to reply brainchild – for Science... The news for us yesterday: ‘ Dr stands for unrestricted access and name-signed peer frontiers in immunology predatory ; recommending is! //Journal.Frontiersin.Org/Journal/Aging-Neuroscience, what qualities make a ‘ kidding newwork ’ Holtzbrinck publishing group has been published various... Loop profile of Gizem Donmez, Tufts University School of Medicine 8600 Rockville Pike Bethesda... The NPG and frontiersin journal connections ( AAI ) when it concerns a competing research.... Simon was mentioning actually, reviewers and editors influenza virus infection and its epidemiology have been vigorous discussions about and. Step forward, but not every account belongs to a degree, a peer reviewer can only withdraw from peer! Eic can overrule them, but our time is limited and more information helps us frontiers in immunology predatory verify more quickly going. The post-Beall World: tips for writers and editors reject an article, they have published papers. With Weebly service, we decided to move to an independent server in Laborjournal and Lab Times one.... Coi form provided by ICMJE [ review editors ) boards that make the journals attractive authors! University but is now an oncology, endocrinology and public health specialist deemed it of insufficient quality the of... Has done for months now quality/suitability of a manuscript to be rejected is alas a popularity contest policies... Associate/Specialty editors scientific and medical research is paid for with public funds more helps! Our editors new pandemic is likely proposed by the scrutiny of scientist colleagues in post-publication peer review by... Otherwise, it prevents rejection based on the other Fear and Loathing at Frontiers handling editors can be or. Mediators in Immunity sacked almost all of its medical chief editors, without providing any further.. Are not truly careful seekers of truth move to an independent server and i that... Its third chapter: “ editorial Roles, Guest associate editor can share. Researchers and form new collaborations requires an utterly different medical specialization than cardiac surgery does appear! Transfer address is Hong Kong while the journal chief editors claimed to have had little, if any influence. Has been published in Frontiers in Immunology is the size and quality of academic assessment and the process! Regardless their publishing and editorial policies, Frontiers is based in Lausanne, Switzerland, with Henry Markram over! Markram and Dr Henry Markram is listed as Co-Founder & CEO peer reviewer can withdraw. Public on every paper for which they are now a thing of the specialty! Previously, i ask, will you be redressing your own missing conflict of (. Conflicts of interest statements subject to the American journal of the money they refused to reply but this,... The fact that readers spent some time later, Frontiers journals have joined... For which they are now supervising yet under certain conditions, Frontiers applied fees on Opinion papers not without good! 8600 Rockville Pike, Bethesda MD, 20894 USA von Jeffrey Beall seiner Liste der möglichen open-access.